Discover the 10 insurance KPIs that can help you streamline your process and improve profitability.

In today’s fast-paced and competitive insurance market, staying ahead of the curve requires strategic planning, informed decision-making, and constant performance tracking. But how do district managers measure their effectiveness? This is where Key Performance Indicators, or KPIs, come into play.

Importance of KPIs in the Insurance Business

Understanding KPIs

Think of KPIs as a GPS for your business – they guide you toward your goal by providing real-time, actionable insights. They are quantifiable measures that help gauge the performance of various aspects of your business.

Role of Insurance KPIs 

In the insurance sector, KPIs are crucial for assessing policy effectiveness, underwriting profitability, customer service, and many other facets of the business. In addition, they provide district managers with a clear snapshot of their department’s performance and where improvements are needed.

Let’s dive deeper into the key KPIs all district managers should have on their radar.

insurance KPIs

The 10 Insurance KPIs You Can’t Do Without

1. Policy Renewal Rates

The Policy Renewal Rate is a Key Performance Indicator (KPI) that measures the proportion of policyholders who choose to renew their insurance policies with your company. It’s a significant indicator of customer satisfaction and loyalty, both critical factors for success in the insurance industry.

Here’s how it works: Let’s say you’re a district manager at an insurance company and have 1,000 policyholders whose policies are up for renewal in a particular month. Of these 1,000 policyholders, 800 decide to renew their policies with your company. This would mean your Policy Renewal Rate is 80% for that month.

A higher Policy Renewal Rate is a positive sign for insurance businesses. It indicates that customers are satisfied with the service they’re receiving and see value in continuing their relationship with your company. It’s a vote of confidence in your business, offerings, and customer service. On the other hand, a lower Policy Renewal Rate might indicate that policyholders are not fully satisfied, and it’s time to investigate why and how you can improve.

Tracking Policy Renewal Rates can offer vital insights into customer satisfaction, customer loyalty, and the overall health of your customer relationships. By monitoring this KPI, district managers can identify areas for improvement and make data-driven decisions to boost customer retention and loyalty.

2. Customer Acquisition Cost

Customer Acquisition Cost, often abbreviated as CAC, is a crucial business metric that quantifies the cost of winning a customer to purchase a product/service or subscribe to any business model.

In simpler terms, CAC is the total cost of your sales and marketing efforts that are needed to attract a new customer over a specific period. This cost includes advertising, promotions, sales personnel, commissions, overhead, and other expenses that go directly into acquiring new customers.

The formula to calculate CAC is pretty straightforward: You take the total amount you’ve spent on acquiring customers (marketing expenses) and divide it by the number of customers you acquired in the period you’re measuring.

For example, if you spent $50,000 on marketing in a year and acquired 500 customers in the same year, your CAC is $100 per customer.

Why is CAC critical, you might ask? Understanding this metric helps businesses gauge the return on their marketing investments, identify the most cost-efficient channels for customer acquisition, and predict financial performance. For example, if the CAC is too high, it might indicate that a company is spending too much to attract customers, which can affect profitability. Conversely, a low CAC might suggest that a company efficiently converts its marketing efforts into new customers.

For district managers in the insurance industry, monitoring CAC is crucial. It aids them in making informed decisions about their marketing strategies and budget allocations, ultimately leading to more sustainable growth and profitability. Aiming for a lower CAC is always a good practice, as it signifies higher efficiency in acquiring new customers.

3. Claim Settlement Ratio

The Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) is a critical metric in the insurance industry that measures the percentage of claims settled by the insurance company out of the total claims received during a specified period.

Here’s a simple way to calculate it: Take the number of insurance claims the company settled in a given period and divide it by the total number of claims received during that period. Then, multiply the result by 100 to get the ratio as a percentage.

For example, if an insurance company received 1,000 claims and successfully settled 950, the Claim Settlement Ratio would be (950/1000) * 100 = 95%.

This ratio is critical for both customers and insurance providers. From a customer’s perspective, a higher CSR implies that the insurance company is more likely to settle claims, which increases trust and confidence in the company’s reliability. From an insurance provider’s perspective, maintaining a high CSR is crucial for building a solid reputation and attracting and retaining customers.

A high CSR is a hallmark of an insurance company that values its policyholders and operates transparently and efficiently. However, a low CSR may raise red flags and cause potential difficulties or delays in claim settlements. This could deter potential customers and harm the company’s reputation.

Therefore, it’s in the best interest of district managers to closely monitor their company’s CSR and strive to keep it as high as possible. Addressing claim disputes promptly and efficiently, ensuring a smooth claim process, and providing excellent customer service are all strategies that can help improve an insurance company’s Claim Settlement Ratio.

4. Loss Ratio

The Loss Ratio is a crucial financial metric for insurance companies that compares the total claims paid out to policyholders with the total premiums collected. It’s used to evaluate an insurance provider’s profitability and overall financial health.

To calculate the Loss Ratio, divide the total claims paid out by the premiums earned and then multiply the result by 100 to get a percentage.

For example, if an insurance company collected $1 million in premiums and paid out $700,000 in claims, the Loss Ratio would be ($700,000 / $1,000,000) * 100 = 70%.

A high Loss Ratio may indicate that the insurance company is paying out more in claims than it’s collecting in premiums, which can negatively impact profitability. It may also signal that the company’s underwriting practices are too lenient or experiencing a high volume of claims due to external factors such as natural disasters or market conditions.

On the other hand, a low Loss Ratio may indicate that the company is generating more revenue through premiums than it’s paying out in claims, which could be a sign of healthy profitability. However, a meager Loss Ratio might also suggest that the company is being too conservative in its underwriting or not providing adequate coverage to its policyholders.

As a district manager, keeping a close eye on your company’s Loss Ratio is essential. A balanced Loss Ratio signifies a well-managed insurance company that adequately prices its policies while providing adequate coverage to its customers. 

5. Combined Ratio

The Combined Ratio is a metric commonly used in the insurance industry to evaluate the financial performance of an insurance company. It measures the insurer’s ability to generate underwriting profits and is calculated by dividing the sum of the company’s losses and expenses by its earned premiums.

The formula for calculating the Combined Ratio is as follows:

Combined Ratio = (Losses + Expenses) / Earned Premiums

The Loss Ratio is the portion of the premium paid out as claims. The Expense Ratio represents the expenses incurred by the insurer in underwriting and administering policies, including salaries, rent, and other overhead costs.

A Combined Ratio of less than 100% indicates that the insurer is profitable in underwriting operations. In comparison, a ratio of greater than 100% indicates that the insurer is paying out more in claims and expenses than it is receiving in premiums. In other words, a Combined Ratio of less than 100% means that the insurer is earning more than it is spending on claims and expenses, while a ratio of greater than 100% means that the insurer is losing money.

insurance KPIs

6. Customer Retention Rate

The customer retention rate indicates how satisfied customers are with the insurance products and services provided by the company. If the retention rate is high, it indicates that customers are happy with the service they are receiving and are likely to renew their policies, resulting in increased revenue for the company.

On the other hand, a low retention rate could indicate that customers are dissatisfied with the company’s products or services, resulting in lost business and revenue. In such a scenario, the district manager must investigate the reasons for the low retention rate and take appropriate measures to improve customer satisfaction.

The customer retention rate reflects the company’s ability to maintain long-term customer relationships. Retaining existing customers is often less expensive than acquiring new ones. As such, high customer retention rates can help to reduce customer acquisition costs, which can be a significant expense for insurance companies.

Moreover, maintaining long-term customer relationships can increase customer loyalty, resulting in positive word-of-mouth recommendations and referrals. This, in turn, can lead to more business opportunities for the district manager and the insurance company.

Finally, a high retention rate can be a competitive advantage for the district manager and the company. In the insurance industry, customer loyalty is critical, and companies with high retention rates are often viewed more favorably by customers and competitors alike.

Customer retention rate is one of the important insurance KPIs for district managers to watch, as it provides insights into customer satisfaction, long-term customer relationships, and competitive advantage. By improving customer retention rates, district managers can drive business growth, reduce costs, and improve the company’s overall health.

7. Net Promoter Score

The Net Promoter Score is a powerful tool used to gauge the loyalty of a company’s customer relationships. It is an alternative to traditional customer satisfaction research and claims to be correlated with revenue growth.

NPS is calculated based on responses to a single question: “On a scale of 0-10, how likely are you to recommend our company/product/service to a friend or colleague?” 

Those who respond with a score of 9 to 10 are called ‘Promoters.’ They are considered loyal enthusiasts who keep buying and referring others, fueling growth. Those who score 0 to 6 are labeled ‘Detractors,’ unhappily stuck in their relationship with your company, and likely to damage your brand through negative word-of-mouth. Finally, those who respond with a 7 or 8 are termed ‘Passives,’ satisfied but unenthusiastic customers vulnerable to competitive offerings.

Your company’s NPS is calculated by subtracting the percentage of customers who are Detractors from those who are Promoters. Passive scores are not directly considered when calculating the NPS, although their improvement can indirectly increase a company’s score by reducing the number of Detractors.

The final score can range from -100 (if every customer is a Detractor) to +100 (if every customer is a Promoter). A positive NPS (>0) is generally deemed suitable, an NPS of +50 is excellent, and anything over +70 is considered world-class.

Utilizing NPS, district managers can identify the overall customer sentiment towards their company and work towards improving their products and services based on the feedback provided. It’s a great way to turn customer feedback into actionable insights to enhance customer experience and loyalty.

8. Average Revenue per Customer (ARPC)

ARPC is a measure of the average amount of revenue generated by each customer. This metric is essential because it provides insights into how much revenue the company generates per customer. By analyzing ARPC, district managers can identify opportunities to increase revenue by targeting higher-value customers or cross-selling additional products to existing customers.

ARPC can be used to track revenue trends over time. If the ARPC is increasing, it suggests that the company is doing well in generating more revenue per customer. In contrast, if the ARPC is decreasing, the company may be losing customers or not generating as much revenue per customer. District managers can use this information to develop strategies to improve revenue per customer.

ARPC is a valuable metric for comparing the performance of the company’s products and services. For example, district managers can use ARPC to compare the revenue generated by life insurance policies versus home insurance policies. This information can be used to identify which products and services are the most profitable and to make informed decisions about where to allocate resources.

Finally, ARPC is a critical metric for forecasting future revenue. By analyzing historical ARPC data and market trends, district managers can make informed predictions about future revenue and adjust their strategies accordingly.

Average Revenue per Customer (ARPC) is an important KPI for district managers in the insurance industry as it provides insights into revenue per customer, revenue trends over time, product and service profitability, and future revenue forecasting. By analyzing ARPC data, district managers can make informed decisions about increasing revenue and optimizing product and service offerings.

9. Profitability Ratio

The Profitability Ratio measures the company’s profitability by comparing its net income to its revenue. A high Profitability Ratio indicates that the company is generating a significant profit from its operations, which is a crucial indicator of financial health. As such, district managers can use this KPI to assess the company’s overall profitability and make informed decisions about allocating resources and investments.

Profitability Ratio is an essential metric for evaluating the effectiveness of the company’s cost management and pricing strategies. By analyzing this ratio, district managers can identify whether the company effectively manages its costs and generates revenue through appropriate pricing strategies.

Profitability Ratio can help district managers to identify areas where the company can improve its profitability. For instance, a low profitability ratio may suggest that the company incurs high costs or has an inefficient pricing strategy. By identifying the root causes of low profitability, district managers can take steps to address them, such as implementing cost-cutting measures or revising pricing strategies.

The Profitability Ratio is also a valuable metric for assessing the company’s financial performance compared to its competitors. By comparing the company’s Profitability Ratio with that of its competitors, district managers can identify whether the company is performing better or worse than its competitors in terms of generating profits. This information can be used to make informed decisions about pricing strategies, product offerings, and other business strategies.

10. Expense Ratio

Expense Ratio measures the company’s efficiency in managing its expenses. It is calculated by dividing the company’s operating expenses by its earned premiums. A low Expense Ratio indicates that the company is operating efficiently. At the same time, a high Expense Ratio suggests that the company may be spending too much on expenses relative to its revenue.

Expense Ratio is an essential metric for comparing the efficiency of the company’s operations to its competitors. District managers can use this KPI to identify whether the company’s expenses align with industry standards or whether there are opportunities to reduce costs and improve efficiency.

Expense Ratio is a valuable metric for forecasting future profitability. By analyzing historical Expense Ratio data and trends, district managers can make informed predictions about future expenses and adjust their strategies accordingly to improve profitability. 

Utilizing KPIs for Effective Decision Making

Linking KPIs to Strategy

KPIs are only as valuable as the insights they provide. Therefore, district managers should align their insurance KPIs with the company’s overall strategy, ensuring that they’re tracking the most relevant metrics to achieve their business goals.

Data-driven Decisions

Informed decision-making relies on accurate data. District managers can make data-driven decisions by closely monitoring these KPIs, optimizing resources, and maximizing profits.


In conclusion, understanding and tracking these ten insurance KPIs is crucial for district managers to stay ahead of the competition. By regularly monitoring these metrics, managers can make data-driven decisions, improve customer satisfaction, and drive business success.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Why are KPIs important in the insurance industry?

KPIs are important because they help assess the performance of various aspects of the business, such as policy effectiveness, underwriting profitability, and customer service.

2. How do I know which KPIs to track?

KPIs should align with your company’s overall strategy and goals. Select those that are most relevant to your department’s objectives and the company’s overall vision.

3. How often should I review my KPIs?

KPIs should be reviewed regularly, with the frequency depending on the specific KPI and your business needs. For example, some may need daily monitoring, while others require weekly or monthly assessments.

4. Can I track more than ten KPIs?

Yes, you can track as many insurance KPIs as necessary for your business. However, focus on the most relevant and impactful ones to avoid information overload.

5. What is the best way to present KPIs to my team?

Presenting KPIs through visual aids like graphs, charts, or dashboards can effectively communicate performance data and engage your team.

At HBW Leads, specialists call on your behalf to capture ideal prospects, so you can focus on converting clients and hitting your sales targets. No other agent has access to your list. It’s the perfect solution to complement your other lead generation efforts. Request a quote today.