A Guide for Insurance Agency Owners Training New Agents

As an insurance agency owner, one of the most crucial skills you can teach your new agents is effectively building rapport with clients over the phone. In an industry where trust and personal connections are paramount, mastering the art of phone communication can be the key to success. This guide will provide you with a comprehensive training plan to help your new agents develop the skills needed to establish solid and lasting relationships with clients, all while conducting business over the phone.

Understanding the Importance of Rapport in Insurance Sales

Before diving into specific techniques, it’s vital to help your new agents understand why building rapport is critical in the insurance industry. Here are some key points to emphasize:

  1. Trust: Insurance is a trust-based business. Clients entrust your agency with their financial security and the protection their most valuable assets. Building rapport helps establish the trust needed for clients to feel confident in your agency’s ability to meet their needs.
  2. Loyalty: Strong rapport fosters client loyalty. When agents take the time to build genuine connections with clients, those clients are more likely to stick with your agency for the long haul, even in the face of competition.
  3. Referrals: Satisfied clients who strongly connect with your agency are more likely to refer friends and family, helping your business grow organically.
  4. Effective Communication: Rapport allows for more effective communication. When clients feel comfortable with your agents, they’re more likely to openly share their needs, concerns, and goals, allowing your agents to provide better-tailored solutions.

Building Rapport Over the Phone

4 Key Elements of Building Rapport Over the Phone

Now that your new agents understand the “why” behind building rapport, it’s time to teach them the “how.” Here are four key elements to focus on:

1. Active Listening

One of the most critical aspects of building rapport is making the client feel heard and understood. Train your agents to practice active listening by:

  • Giving the client their full attention and minimizing distractions
  • Using verbal cues like “mhm” and “I understand” to show they’re engaged
  • Paraphrasing and repeating back key points to confirm understanding
  • Asking clarifying questions to gain deeper insight into the client’s needs

2. Empathy and Emotional Intelligence

Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another. Teach your agents to tune into the client’s emotional state and respond accordingly. This might involve:

  • Acknowledging and validating the client’s concerns or frustrations
  • Showing genuine care and interest in the client’s well-being
  • Using a warm, understanding tone of voice
  • Offering support and reassurance when needed

3. Personalization and Common Ground

Building rapport over the phone or in person involves finding common ground and making the interaction feel personalized. Encourage your agents to:

  • Use the client’s name throughout the conversation
  • Look for opportunities to connect over shared interests or experiences
  • Reference past conversations or interactions to show they remember and value the client
  • Tailor their communication style to the client’s preferences (e.g., formal vs. casual, detailed vs. big-picture)

4. Positive Language and Tone

The agents’ language and tone can significantly impact the client’s perception of the interaction. Train your agents to:

  • Use positive, optimistic language that focuses on solutions rather than problems
  • Smile while speaking, as this can be “heard” through the phone and makes the tone more friendly
  • Avoid industry jargon or technical terms that may confuse or alienate the client
  • Maintain a professional yet warm and conversational tone throughout the call

Putting it into Practice: Role-Playing and Feedback

Once your agents understand the critical elements of building rapport, it’s time to put their skills into practice. Set up role-playing scenarios where agents can take turns playing the client and the agent. Have them practice various scenarios, such as:

  • A new client is calling for a quote
  • An existing client calling with a question or concern about their policy
  • A client called to report a claim

As they role-play, provide feedback and coaching on their rapport-building techniques. Offer specific examples of what they did well and areas where they could improve. Encourage them to self-reflect on their performance and set goals for improvement.

Measuring Success and Ongoing Coaching

Establish metrics to track their progress to ensure your agents are successfully building rapport with clients. This might include:

  • Client satisfaction scores or surveys
  • Retention and renewal rates
  • Referral numbers
  • Sales conversion rates

Review these metrics regularly with your agents and provide ongoing coaching and training to help them refine their skills continually.


Building rapport over the phone is a skill that can be learned and mastered with the proper training and practice. Equipping your new agents with the tools and techniques outlined in this guide will set them up for success in establishing strong, lasting client relationships. Remember, building rapport is not a one-time event but an ongoing process that requires consistent effort and attention.

With a commitment to continuous improvement and a focus on empathy, active listening, and personalization, your agents will be well on their way to becoming rapport-building experts, driving success for your agency, and providing exceptional value to your clients.

While you focus on training, let us focus on leads. At HBW Leads, specialists call on your behalf to capture ideal leads, so the prospecting work is done for you. Start boosting sales today.